I am currently trying out "Elite Singles". I have never done online dating (and didn't do much in the way of dating period). I find it pretty user friendly. I haven't had super creepy people as of yet either. And I have met a guy that I've been talking to for a couple weeks now. I have no clue if anything will come of it, but I'm enjoying just learning about someone and having some good conversation. So, it's a good one to dip your toes into. It is for people looking for serious relationships, so everyone so far has been pretty upfront about what they're looking for. It does have a monthly membership fee (which I like, because it seems to keep out a lot of people that I would not be interested in).