Offline
Thank you for writing Julian and others. In reply to Julian's post:
1. That's the thing that sort of haunts me the most. My story is a little bit different than what I've come across. My husband told me he was bisexual about 9 years into our relationship. He admitted that he'd known since about puberty, but that he'd never had any same-sex encounters. I found no porn, no texts, no emails, or apps...and since we've both worked from home for years and are together 99% of the time...there simply would not have been any opportunity for infidelity. (I did get an STD test anyway!) It's been close to 2 years now, and he's never asked for an open relationship or "hall pass" or simulated gay sex (as you call it) or a threesome even.
Ok. I have a question for you: if everything appears to be ok with your relationship, why did you join this forum?
2. In fact, it seems his attraction to men is more romantic (as I said..unusual)...which is odd because...while we've always had a pretty strong sexual attraction (since the day we met), he's never been particularly romantic...We have lots of sex, but we don't cuddle while watching a movie...or hold hands, etc...for example. So, after a few rough weeks/months post-disclosure, nothing has really changed...except for the fact that I've developed a "waiting for the other shoe to drop" syndrome....and I worry (after reading so many stories): Can he possibly be faking his way through it?...(all of the sex)...or will he (for lack of a better way to put this) grow gayer with age? (He's 36 now)
Every journey is unique my friend. I'm also starting to appreciate how difficult it is for gay-in-denial spouses to "just come out." If I think back to my own (long) coming out process, there are similarities to what you've shared. It first started with a sexual disconnect, meaning that while I could mechanically have sex with my (then) wife in my 20s and 30s, there was never any passion. Here are some common "symptoms" I've read about here which apply to my former marriage:
- Gay-in-denial husband rarely initiates sex
- The relationship is mostly dry kisses and squirmy hugs
- The relationship feels more like brother/sister or roommates than lovers
- As the GIDH ages, sex becomes more infrequent and might even stop
As I've shared many times before, while a GIDH can lie up and down, "I'm straight and I don't want to be in a relationship with a man!" there is no lying in the bedroom, nor online, nor in some sticky adult store backroom.
I want to thank everyone posting here, asking questions, and challenging me because I've learned something important while discussing men who are "emotionally straight and yet sexually gay." I reckon the reason so many married, closeted men resist just saying "I'm gay" and/or divorcing is because it represents too seismic a shift in their lives. In my opinion, closeted husbands continue to claim they are straight because a married man with a straight wife, kids, straight family, straight friends, and oftentimes a straight congregation has absolutely NO incentive to come out, separate, and divorce. It represents losing everything. Yes there is an argument to be made about gay men being "authentic", but I myself hesitated when that "authenticity" mean tearing my family apart, losing my home, financial ruin, and isolation/loneliness. Even after I'd come out to my wife, our marriage limped along for 18 long months before we finally separated/divorced. I believe this is why many gay-in-denial husbands don't just "come out." It's fear.
3. Wow..I'm rambling. I don't even think I have a question...but maybe someone will find similarities between my story and theirs (and we can commiserate over our shared confusion...haha). Thanks, everyone, for tuning in.
Ramble away! That's what this forum is for. This forum is a safe space for everyone to share their innermost thoughts and, most importantly, get the support they need. Be well everyone!
Last edited by Séan (November 13, 2020 2:55 am)
Offline
Julian,
What you have described sounds a lot like my husband. He wants to have sex but he has more of a connection and gets more enthused and excited about his male relationships. We rarely (if ever) hold hands or cuddle on the couch. I have asked him if he is bisexual and he has denied it but then 2 weeks after that conversation, he wanted to know if I minded if he went on a week long "writing trip" with his best friend (also married) to a beach house. I, of course, told him to go ahead. I want him to do what he wants to do. I want out. But in the back of my mind, I think, who goes on a week long trip with another male, two weeks after your wife has questioned your sexuality?
His male relationships are just that important to him. What I feel like I am missing out on the most, is passion and desire. I know he loves me and cares for me but, that spark where he caresses your cleavage or grabs your thigh, or butt never happens for me because he never touches me like that. He is incapable of doing that. He will have sex with me and those are the only times that I get touched sexually, but then it starts to feel like I am being used. How can you not have desire for me during the day but yet have sex with me at night?
He has a couple or possibly more than that gay friends that he talks with regularly. I wonder if I've just been blind and in denial myself all these years that he has acted this way. I know he doesn't desire me in the ways that he should and I probably should've realized this a long time ago. I also feel like he doesn't respect me in the ways that he should. He can be belittling and demeaning to me at times. He can also be very controlling and manipulative and there is always an element of anger right below the surface. He is also a clean freak and likes to keep things in order and in place. He rearranges the dishwasher and the grocery cart after I have loaded something because his way is the best way.
He has long conversations on the phone with his male friends and they seem to talk about everything. It seems like he can open up more to his male friends than he can to me. He seems to filter everything he says to me. He never really seems to be present to me and always seems to have his mind on other things. I haven't found concrete proof either as far as sexual texts or hook ups, but I know how I have felt for 22 years and I know that I can't spend the rest of my life this way.
One more thing about sex....we don't undress in front of each other. I undress in the closet or the bathroom-same for him. When we are done having sex he straightens the bed and has my pajamas laid out on the comforter for me to put back on. Sometimes during sex (this is weird af) he will readjust the covers or get self conscious if his butt is touching the covers. He will literally move the covers during sex because he doesn't want his butt to touch the covers where his face will be later....who the fuck thinks of that during sex? Sorry for my language but I've been really angry for a while now. We don't cuddle naked. At the beginning of our marriage, he told me that he did not want to have oral sex because he felt like it was demeaning to me. He never asked for it or wanted it, until 2 years ago when I told him that I needed to have my needs met and he was worried that I was going to divorce him. Only then would he perform oral sex on me, and the first time after he did it, he went to the bathroom and washed his mouth out with mouthwash. nice. He claims that that doesn't mean anything and that he just likes to do that (wash his mouth out). I haven't given him many blow jobs bec he never asks for them or wants them but when I do, he never orgasms and I don't think I am that terrible at it. He is extremely concerned about image, which I believe is why he is so in denial. He used to be a pastor but is no longer pastoring. His Dad was also a pastor.
Anyway, I just wanted to get a bit of my story out there for Julian or for Sean to comment or anyone else. I am so thankful to Sean and to this board for the help that they offer. It feels like being with a group who totally understands everything. I used to look at other women with their husbands and how their husbands touched and caressed them, and how they cherished, and spoke proudly of their wives and I wished my husband was more like that. I thought it was just his personality and that I'd have to live with it because he had a lot of other really good qualities, but now I see that not desiring your wife is a sexual problem not a personality problem. It seems so simple when you write it out like that but when you are living it, it can be very confusing. Love to everyone on this board. We'll get through these struggles.
Offline
Julian,
I’m curious. Did your husband tell you why he decided to tell you? I’d guess there had to be a reason.
Tangled
Offline
Sean, thank you for your reply. My son and his wife are both in counseling separately, and she has told him that she doesn't want it to be this way. They have struggled and cried together, mourning what they thought their future would be. She did tell him she was bisexual at the beginning of their relationship, which he was ok with. I guess that should have been a red flag. She also told him about the abuse from the beginning. I may be blinded by being too close, but I kind of feel like she is sincere, based on their history together and what I have known about her. I still think you are right, they should divorce and go their separate ways. And as blunt as it is, the marriage died when she came out, as you said. Thanks for the reality check. He just got on antidepressants, I'm hoping that will help him see things clearly, and make it possible for him to plan for the future.
Offline
Thank you for posting SadMom. In reply:
1. Sean, thank you for your reply.
My pleasure. I hope your son is feeling better.
2. My son and his wife are both in counseling separately, and she has told him that she doesn't want it to be this way.
I'm not surprised. Please ensure that your son doesn't attend couples' counselling because their marriage is clearly over. I am not a mental health professional so please read my comments accordingly. Following "discovery" or "disclosure" of a spouse's homosexuality, some gay/straight couples attend counselling together. This rarely helps the straight spouse. My (then) wife and I tried couples counselling and it was a disaster. Sadly, our joint counselling sessions did nothing to help my (former) straight spouse as the focus became my sexuality. If a gay/gay-in-denial spouse claims "sexual abuse made me gay", there is also the very real possibility that couples counselling focuses on that as well. I reckon couples counselling should be about fixing a relationship, not a therapy session exclusively for the gay spouse while a long-suffering straight partner looks on....or worse is somehow blamed for the relationship's problems. Based on my own experience and based on my many exchanges here, most straight spouses come away from joint counselling sessions feeling like they have to do more to save the relationship. That's some straight up bullsh*t.
2. They have struggled and cried together, mourning what they thought their future would be.
Good. If they're mourning then they both understand the relationship is dead...and will eventually be buried.
3. She did tell him she was bisexual at the beginning of their relationship, which he was ok with.
Let's rephrase that: "She admitted to hiding/lying about her sexuality from the beginning."
4. I guess that should have been a red flag.
Amen!
5. She also told him about the abuse from the beginning. I may be blinded by being too close, but I kind of feel like she is sincere, based on their history together and what I have known about her.
Let me be clear regarding my opinion about gay/gay-in-denial spouses who claim "sexual abuse/assault made me gay" because it's a very common occurrence. There are two possibilities: 1. the gay spouse is lying; or 2. the gay spouse is telling the truth. If the spouse has a history of honesty and integrity, claims of sexual abuse might be true. If however, the gay spouse has a lifelong history of lying and cheating, such claims are likely false. So what's my point? I reckon gay-in-denial (GID) spouses aren't evil. We are simply incapable of being honest about our sexuality because we've lied about being gay our entire lives.
6. I still think you are right, they should divorce and go their separate ways.
Agreed. Gay/straight marriages simply don't work. If your daughter-in-law is a lesbian, there is no reason for them to remain married other than to continue the lie that she is somehow heterosexual. Please help your son detach with love, separate, and divorce as quickly as possible..
7. And as blunt as it is, the marriage died when she came out, as you said. Thanks for the reality check. He just got on antidepressants, I'm hoping that will help him see things clearly, and make it possible for him to plan for the future.
A future without her.
Thanks for sharing my friend. Please keep posting.
Offline
Sean,
In your opinion do you think my husband sounds gay to you? I’m really struggling to know what to do. I really don’t have concrete evidence. I wish I did.
Last edited by Karis (November 15, 2020 3:06 pm)
Offline
Hi Karis. Your husband certainly ticks all of the "pink" boxes:
- Has never really had an interest in straight sex
- Boyfriend-like relationships with gay men
- An obsessive interest in gay culture
- Checks men out when you're out with him
- You feel like you're living with a roommate, rather than a husband
I can imagine that the absence of concrete proof, such as a gay porn history or an affair with a man, gives you pause. It shouldn't. When I first started posting here, I'd often tell straight spouses to trust their instincts. I still believe that if a straight spouse is posting here about her husband, he's probably gay. But let's take a step back and just look at your marriage. You're clearly unhappy in your relationship and you were justifiably considering an affair you were so starved for attention. While I've only scanned your message history here, I reckon you're desperately unhappy in your marriage so whether your husband is gay (or not) really isn't the issue. If you are depressed, angry, and sexually unsatisfied, please keep in mind that people have separated/divorced for much less my friend. So is your husband gay? I say it doesn't really matter. What you've shared here is that your husband appears to be more emotionally invested in his gay friends than he's invested in your marriage. Perhaps it's time to consider separation and divorce. I hope that helps in some way my friend.
Last edited by Sean (November 15, 2020 4:12 pm)
Offline
Thanks so much Sean. Ive always appreciated your input and your willingness to be on this board. I really feel like it helps so many people. It’s very kind of you. Thanks for reading my post history and providing your thoughts. It’s hard to make such a difficult decision about leaving when there are kids involved. My kids are older now (20 and 17) but it still feels tough. Thank you again!
Offline
There often comes a point in the straight wife's journey when it no longer matters whether her husband admits he is gay or not. She eventually understands that the marriage is beyond repair and won't likely improve. A small minority of couples separate and then divorce almost immediately following disclosure/discovery of the husband's homosexuality. The majority of couples follow the path of: discovery; conflict; marriage counselling; reconciliation; and then a honeymoon phase (he pretends to be a straight husband or she simulates being a gay man in the bedroom). The cycle often repeats 5-7 times before the straight spouse finally accepts her husband is gay, always was gay, and that no amount of counselling nor prayer will change that. So what's my point? Marriages can often be like an ocean supertanker - those huge ocean transport ships. A supertanker can't just turn on a dime and they take many nautical miles to change direction. Changing course in a decades-long marriage similarly means slowly turning by a few degrees at a time. Rare is the straight spouse who just cries, "I want a divorce!" and then departs the next day. So I urge straight spouses to methodically work towards ending their toxic relationships.
1. Detaching:
The first stage often requires her to detach with love. After years of lies, sexual neglect, cheating and emotional abuse, a gay-in-denial husband (GIDH) often has a firm hold on his long-suffering straight wife. Detaching with love can start with just turning off your phone for an hour, then two, or perhaps by responding to every other text sent by a GIDH. Try spending time away from your toxic husband to see things more clearly. This means individual counseling, solo time with close friends/family, and perhaps a much-needed weekend away. If your GIDH displays narcissistic tendencies, be prepared for a "love bombing" or "honeymoon" phase if he fears losing control. This means he will pretend to love you to win you back and it might even mean a short-lived interest in straight sex. It won't last. After a few weeks or months, he'll revert back to being the same cheating, porn-watching, gay-in-denial (GID) *sshole.
2. Separation:
Before separation, the straight spouse should consult with a lawyer regarding how to properly plan for divorce. Separation often starts with physical separation. This means the spouses sleep separately, no longer attempt sex, and start the long process of separating their lives. The gay husband may even move out for a time. Again the straight spouse should be prepared for more love bombing (see above) or perhaps even some manufactured crisis like an attempted suicide. During the separation stage, this is also when your husband will likely claim he was sexually abused. (See my previous posts about men who claim "childhood abuse made me gay). If the straight spouse still feels an overwhelming need to protect and/or heal her husband, she should start reading about co-dependency and discuss the same with a qualified therapist.
3. Divorce:
Once the straight spouse decides to divorce, things often go two ways. The first path is your gay-in-denial husband accepts the end of the marriage and just moves on. He moves out and goes through gay adolescence which is a period of teen-like sexual/emotional discovery. Put bluntly, he acts like a self-centered gay teen and may even dress like one. This path may also mean he finally (and almost triumphantly) discloses a long-term relationship...with a man or a woman. (Some GIDHs are so trapped in denial that they date/marry another woman just as a final "f*ck you I AM STRAIGHT!" to a future ex-wife.) The second path is somewhat darker and more troubling. Some gay-in-denial husbands (GIDHs) become verbally or emotionally abusive. They act this way perhaps out of anger of losing their "beard", being outed, or in some f*cked up attempt to force a straight wife back into the relationship.
Please keep in mind that the above represents my personal opinions. I'm just sharing my experience and have no professional mental health training. As such, I urge all straight spouses to consult with mental health professional and divorce lawyers to properly prepare for separation and divorce. Thanks for reading friends.
If any straight spouses have questions for a gay ex-husband, ask away. Be well!
Last edited by Sean (November 16, 2020 6:33 am)
Offline
Hi Longwayhome (LWH). In response to your post:
1. I'm 14 months post discovery, my husband identifies as bi and over the last decade or so this has been playing out behind the scene (as they all do).
I'm so very sorry you and your son are suffering my friend. Here is my personal opinion about cheating husbands who suddenly claim "I'm bisexual."
- If he has a history of lying, keep in mind that he's the worst judge of his own sexuality.
- Bisexual means an attraction to, and having sex with, both genders (male and female).
- If sex with your husband is infrequent or has stopped altogether, he's likely gay.
- if he's having sex with only men and watches only gay porn, he's likely gay.
2. I shared the text I discovered with my son a couple of days after I found it, before I confronted my husband even. My son at the time was 29 years old (not a kid). I told him because I felt that he had a right to know, as I did, the reason for the hell we had been living under. I never wanted my son to think that somehow our problems had anything to do with him. I still think I did the right thing in telling him. It explained so much.
I think you were wrong to share all of this with your son. Unfortunately, this may have shifted the burden of "dad's secret" to him. I hope that your son is in counselling and/or getting the support he needs. While your son is older (29), I reckon he just wants to live his life, without getting in the middle of his parents' relationship issues. Sorry if that stings my friend.
3. I've told my son on numerous occasions over the last 14 months that I'm here if he wants to talk. My son's wedding was put on hold because of Covid, so the couple is temporarily living with us....
If your husband is currently radioactive, I see no reason why your son and his fiancee should live with you nor be involved with these problems.
4. My son over the last couple of weeks is really showing high signs of anxiety.
Not surprising! Again he and his fiancee should move out...as soon as possible.
5. I know if he were to talk, it would help. I know it helps me to be able to share my story...
You're asking him to talk...about your problems. I'd suggest discussing all of this with your therapist. While sharing your relationship problems with your son makes you feel better, I reckon your problems are the cause of his anxiety. Look while you are still married to your husband, your son is old enough to live on his own. I think he and his bride-to-be should move out.
6. He hasn't been able to do that. The fiance knows too, enough of secrets is my approach within our home. My husband is still in the closet, still demonstrating awful behaviours, although not as bad as pre-discovery.
I've often referred to gay-in-denial husbands as men who are drowning (emotionally). When you see someone drowning in a swimming pool, you throw them a life ring. The last thing you want to do is get in the water with them because you'll just get dragged down to the bottom. Sadly now everyone is in the pool with your flailing husband: you; your son; and your future daughter-in-law. Please help your son get out of the pool, meaning he should move out of the house immediately. While he may be a comfort to you, don't burden him with your relationship problems. With regards to "not as bad as pre-discovery..." I'm not sure much has changed my friend. Or perhaps he's just doing a better job of hiding it.
7. Edited to add: He isn't talking to the fiancee either.....Is there anything I can do or say to help my son open up?
Let's take a step back my friend. It would appear that your son's mental health issues are being caused by his gay-in-denial father and living in a toxic home environment. While I can understand that you need a friend and ally during this difficult time, I'm not sure your son is emotionally equipped to help you. So you should do everything to help your son move out so he can distance himself from his gay-in-denial dad and his parents' dysfunctional marriage. If you still want to help him, book him an appointment with a qualified therapist (not yours) and pay for the therapy sessions.
I hope that helps in some way my friend but please feel free to post again if you disagree or have additional questions.
Last edited by Sean (November 16, 2020 7:36 am)