Offline
I have been with my husband for 15 years (married 8). After years of infertility and failed treatments, we have 2 beautiful boys via IVF (4 years and 3 months old). About 3-4 years ago, my husband confessed to me (while deployed overseas) that he believed he had gender dysphoria. He was confused and having strong, conflicting thoughts on who he was, and wondered if life would be "better" if he was a woman. He reassured me that he wanted to repress these thoughts and wished they would go away; that that wasn't what he truly wanted. He told me over and over again how he was happy with our life and happy as a man - that maybe this was just an identity crisis. Fast forward to today - these feelings and thoughts are happening more frequently. About every 6-10 months (or at least that's when he has the courage to tell me he's having conflicting thoughts). He says they get really strong when he's under a lot of stress (we just had our second child). And in the past year there's been several times that he's referred to these thoughts as a "fantasy." 18 months ago, I also found women's underwear and a bra hidden in his office. He told me they were his and that he only tried wearing them once.
We had another conversation about it last night and I think it just all finally hit home that this isn't just going to go away - like he's tried to reassure me of in the past. And I don't believe he really wants it to go away. He wants to see a doctor or therapist to officially diagnose him with gender dysphoria, and he says he wants to know his options (in a way - he's still trying to give both of us false hope that he can somehow take a pill and we will be able to go on with our life as it is now). I can see that he's scared. He keeps telling me that he loves me. I know that he does. But what possible future can we have? I feel like my whole world has been completely turned upside down. I love him, but I am 1000% a heterosexual woman. And my heartache keeps going back to our children. What will this do to them? I know that sounds incredibly selfish. I keep struggling with feeling guilty for my own feelings when I know that this isn't easy for my husband either. It's not his fault. And I want him to be happy... but I feel so angry too. I feel like a fool. This feels like a nightmare. I don't know what to do.
Offline
Confused, I'm so sorry. It is a nightmare, and unfortunately it's not one from which you are going to wake up. His urges are indeed not going to go away, no matter how hard he tries to "repress" them (my ex described it as like "an itch that is nearly always there"). Men who feel this way often engage in a "binge and purge" cycle of indulging their urge and then repressing it (your husband's secret crossdressing, then his minimizing it or stopping for a time). His shame over the condition is matched by the sexual excitement he feels when he cross dresses and thinks of himself as being a woman. (If you doubt his wanting to be a woman is sexually motivated, ask yourself why of all the female things he might do he chooses wearing women's underwear.)
If you look at your husband's activities, you can see that they have escalated over time (he has gone from saying he believed he was dysphoric to buying women's lingerie for himself, hiding it, and wearing it--and no doubt masturbating while wearing it), and his attitude has evolved from "identity crisis" to "fantasy" to "wants to know his options"--this last will probably include whether he can and what he has to do to transition and live as a woman.
Escalation, unfortunately, defines this condition; the more he does, the more he is excited by it, the more he wants it, the more he does, the more he is excited by it, the more he wants it, the more he does, ad infinitum. The behavior is also accompanied by mental rationalizations--every escalation is rationalized, in the service of what's been done and what more he wants to do.
Have no doubt that he will work very hard to bring you on board, and that includes by telling you he can't help it and doesn't want it--even while he indulges it in secret. It may also include guilting you or appealing to your love for him. I know it feels as if his telling you what he's thinking is a wholly positive thing that indicates your closeness, and it may be this; but it may also be, even partly, strategic or selfish on his part--an attempt to manipulate you to become accustomed to it and/or validate it, or his offloading the problem onto you, so you can take if up as part of your emotional caretaking role, which will increase along with his fascination or engagement with himself as a woman (in direct competition with the needs of your infant and small child).
The question is what are you willing to accept and what you are comfortable with. You know certain things: you are not sexually attracted to women. You are worried about the effect of this condition on your children. It is not selfish at all to worry about the effect of your husband's desire to be a woman on both you and your children. You are not a fool--this is a terribly difficult situation, one none of us has a lot of experience with until it happens to us, and our spouses vacillate in their responses or mislead us for their own benefit. Your husband told you he was happy as a man; why wouldn't you believe this? And why wouldn't we expect our spouses to be trustworthy (until they show us they aren't worthy of our trust)?
The one thing you should not do is contemplate suppressing your own feelings or trying to pretzel yourself into a shape that is acceptable to him but not to you. Please confide in your doctor, a friend or family member who will have your back, and/or a therapist who will help you sort out your own feelings (if you see a therapist who appears to be pushing you to "get on board" with your husband's possible future gender transition get another therapist pronto).
If you are the type who benefits from reading about others in your situaiton, you might want to visit transwidowsvoices.org to read the stories of other women who've been in our situation (my stories are there, as "Alison's story, Part One and Part Two"). The memoir "Sex Changes" by Christine Benevenuto details her experience with her husband's transition, and the effect it had on their children. Another memoir, "18 Months," by Shannon Thrace, details her own experience as her husband became more and more enmeshed in his "female identity." There is also an active online community of women whose husbands declare they are transgender at Mumsnet:
The work by professional and practicing psychologists Michael Bailey ("The Man Who Would Be Queen," available for download on the internet), Ray Blanchard, and Anne Lawrence (Lawrence is transgender) will also give you some insight into what your husband is experiencing.
Here's a podcast with Blanchard:
Here's a podcast with Anne Lawrence:
Last edited by OutofHisCloset (January 3, 2023 10:38 am)