OurPath Open Forum

This Open Forum is funded and administered by OurPath, Inc., (formerly the Straight Spouse Network). OurPath is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit that provides support to Straight Partners and Partners of Trans People who have discovered that their partner is LGBT+. Your contribution, no matter how small, helps us provide our community with this space for discussion and connection.


BE A DONOR >>>


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?



August 8, 2017 10:01 am  #711


Re: A gay ex-husband answers your questions

HI Vee - I'm a little confused.  If he's still your husband and he's still sexually attracted to you then why does he have to control himself and stay away from you?  Are you saying that due to his new relationship with this man that he's trying to be "faithful" to him and stay away from you to honor this man?  If that is indeed what he's saying then I find several major problems with his explanation and this situation. 

1. I think he's full of crap.  If he were so sexually attracted to you that he had to MAKE himself stay away from you then there would be no need to have another person (man or woman) around.  Those are just words.  Men who have strong sexual attractions don't want to stay away to control themselves, they want to jump in and have sex.  He's trying to mislead you by telling you how much he wants to have sex with you.  Men don't tell, they do.  That's not an insult to any man by the way - it's just nature.  Women typically talk about feelings and sex, men act on it.  They don't come up with excuses about why they have to stay away from their wife.

2. If you're still married then why is he "controlling" his sexual urges around you?  If you're the wife and he's trying to control stuff, why isn't he trying to control his feelings for this man and staying away from him not you?? 

Maybe I'm reading it all wrong but his story just doesn't seem to make sense.  Can you tell us a little more?

Glad to see you're still here Sean!

 

August 8, 2017 8:39 pm  #712


Re: A gay ex-husband answers your questions

Well Still wondering I'm confused about why he says he needs to stay away from me too, he says he thinks of me when hes not with me, right up to the day he told me he was having sex with me so I knew of nothing that would suggest anything different as with a gay man who starts to distance himself from his wife...
Yes I guess he is trying to say hes being faithful to this other man lol funny isn't it, because I know he can't honnor being like that any more.... I also know this relationship isn't going to last and that my husband will now need a man in his life...
Yes I'm still his wife but I have taken another approach to it, that I'm no longer the wife that cares in that way...... Building a new relationship and getting along is important to me. 
I see my husband very depressed, he has gone into survival mode which suggests to me hes having problems dealing with being gay...... But that is his problem not mine...
He never had a good relationship with his parents especially his father, so that is why hes attracted to men that are of the older age.... 
I think he is Bisexual and he needs to make a decision to who he want to be with.... At the moment I'm just looking after me and everything we built together....
I'm not stupid and I see things clear now hes not living with me all the time...
I see a lost soul too... But then I know I should be careful not to get caught up in his stuff...
I guess I just want to ask questions still and you think about things..... Then I guess I have to accept it is what is and I should build a bridge and move on aye.....

I hear what your saying - Thank you
 

Last edited by Vee (August 8, 2017 10:00 pm)

 

August 9, 2017 10:39 am  #713


Re: A gay ex-husband answers your questions

Ugh, that's awful Vee, I'm sorry.  The reason I responded to your post is because when I was reading it I noticed a lot of similarities in words (not from my GID ex but from a man I was dating while I was waiting for the divorce to be final).  I was living elsewhere for about a year and a half while I filed (no clue why I didn't just finalize it after the 60 day waiting period but that was my own stupid decision).  Anyway, I was introduced to a man who was also divorcing by a mutual acquaintance.  Very long story short I came to find out he was in fact a master manipulator the likes of which I had never encountered.  To listen to his story you would think his soon to be ex was crazy, his kids were annoyingly out of control, and his life was a chaotic place from which he needed to escape.  Come to find out, none of this was true, including the part that they were divorcing.  And in your post above, I see the same phrases that having been through a manipulation, stand out to me like huge red flags. And in a normal relationship some of these wouldn't be red flags - but when you're talking about someone who absolutely has the ability to be with you but isn't, then your ears should start to perk up.  Phrases like:

"I think of you when I'm not with you"  Well, there's NO reason for him to not be with you, he's the one creating the separation.

"I have to control myself and stay away from you"  Again, why?  There's no reason.  For my situation it was that he needed to "focus" on the divorce.  Huh?  focus? 

You see him in "survival mode".  There's no reason to be in any type of mode.  He is where he wants to be.  Mine literally used the phrase survival mode and used to convey to me on a daily basis how he was just trying to get thru every day.  To look at him you would think his life was in utter turmoil.  Turns out he was remodeling his home the whole time, buying boats, and had only mentioned in passing to his wife that he was not happy.  He used his own friends to search for a girlfriend on the side under the guise that he was divorcing.  It all blew up and yet none of them ever let her know.  They are all still buddies.

Now of course, there are absolutely times in any normal relationship where you might go into survival mode due to hard times or circumstances.  But the difference is that you're living together, sharing things, helping one another go through it.  It could be a death or a lost job or a huge disagreement, but you're still there together, working through it.  However, you don't work through "I think I'm gay or bi so I'm going to go out and have sex elsewhere but tell you that I miss you and have to control myself because my feelings for you are so strong".  Don't buy any of the crap he's selling you.

What I learned from this ex bf was that people are where they want to be and that words are just words.  I know you already know this.  I just wanted to reinforce that you deserve to be more than his second choice.  You deserve to have him come crawling back but to tell him to piss off.  And until you get really pissed about the whole situation, you're in danger of him continuing to use you.  Don't fall for it. I know you know all this.  When I was going through the gay thing I used to tell people I knew it too.  But it took hearing it 295 times before I got up and did something about it.

Hang in there...keep posting.



 

 

August 9, 2017 1:42 pm  #714


Re: A gay ex-husband answers your questions

Thanks Still wondering, He is only eating food, sleeping, going to work and with his boyfriend.
There is nothing that he's happy about when I talk to him, it is like a break down....Nothing in his life is good enough, he hates where we live and everything we have, he just walks away from it all..... But then that is his problem aye.
Its like a little boy not wanting to take responsibility for his actions.
I told him man up and say I have done this, I made all these decision to come to this point, I have messed my own life and mine, so now it is time to move on and deal with things........ 
Its him not accepting his gayness now, not me.... Accepting it hard but I am everyday get easier....

The things you see now when the person leaves are funny, we have grown apart without even seeing it, I have grown with my job where I was wanting to be someone and keep pushing myself.
Where he just wanted to fit in.....He knows how much he has hurt me and he should have told me years ago, as he just didn't know the person I had changed into and he was this naughty little boy who hid things from his wife....

Last night i didn't answer the phone, in 20 years together he would always call me... But I know that I'm on my own, I went to the pub on my own last night I called it a date night on my own lol...
I also had a cry of the loss of my marriage last night..... It is sad but it will be okay I keep telling myself.

Do these kinds of people actually want to help themselves?

Or do they enjoy the pitty party they have?

How about the drama they bring to the table, OMG I have never had so much drama in my life I'm over it!!!!

Maybe these lost souls of sexual cause should get new hobbies or something..........
I'm sorry I get so mad......... The hurting of partners and families should stop...

 

Last edited by Vee (August 9, 2017 1:42 pm)

 

August 14, 2017 12:30 am  #715


Re: A gay ex-husband answers your questions

Thank you for writing Vee. I'm going to try and address your last post. But please keep in mind that I'm sharing my experience and personal opinions. I am not a mental health professional nor an expert on gay/straight relationships. So in reply to your questions:

1. Do these kinds of people [gay husbands who have come out to their wives] actually want to help themselves?

​That's an excellent question Vee. Gay/straight relationships seem to follow a similar evolution. Here is a very brief summary of what I've seen time and time again described here:  

Stage 1 Denial: "I'm not gay. I just watch gay porn because I'm curious."
​Stage 2 Lying/Cheating: "I'm not hooking up with men. I'm just messaging on Craigslist."
Stage 3 Partial Truth: "Yes I had sex once with a guy because I was molested as a child. But I still love you."
Stage 4 More Truth: "Actually I've been having gay hook ups for years. Maybe I'm bisexual."
​Stage 5 The straight spouse starts posting here because she no longer believes her husband. Counseling begins.
​Stage 6 The marriage remains sexless, abusive, and he may now overtly cheat.
​Stage 7 Reality Check: The straight spouse starts considering divorce and may even contact a lawyer.
​Stage 8 Disconnect: The gay spouse is still in denial, while the straight spouse accepts reality...he is gay.
​Stage 9 Separation: The couple separates. The gay spouse is now completely unhinged.
​Stage 10 Divorce: They divorce. Her healing begins. His journey to honesty, authenticity, and acceptance begins...without his "beard."

​To answer your question Vee, I think most gay-in-denial husbands (GIDH) simply want the status quo. This means most want to keep their wives trapped in sexless and abusive marriages so that they can continue the fiction they are straight. GIDHs like me speak a different language: it's called denial. This is the disconnect that leads to the breakdown in most gay/straight marriages in my opinion. He believes a sexless, abusive, and one-sided relationship is perfectly fine because it suits his main purpose: to remain in the closet. This denial can go on for years, if not decades. The relationship breaks down when a straight spouse rightfully calls "bullsh*t" on the whole situation and moves on. You hit the nail on the head with this:

"Thanks Still wondering, He is only eating food, sleeping, going to work and with his boyfriend. There is nothing that he's happy about when I talk to him, it is like a break down....Nothing in his life is good enough, he hates where we live and everything we have, he just walks away from it all..... But then that is his problem aye. Its like a little boy not wanting to take responsibility for his actions. I told him man up and say I have done this, I made all these decisions to come to this point, I have messed my own life and mine, so now it is time to move on and deal with things........ 
Its him not accepting his gayness now, not me.... Accepting it is hard but I am everyday get easier...." 

This perfectly describes the end of a gay/straight relationship. He sounds lost because he's lost you, his "beard." Once the gay/straight relationship breaks down, he has two choices: accept the brutal reality of his situation ("I'm gay, there are real-world consequences, and I have to accept that I've really f*cked up lives here"); or find another wife/beard to continue living in denial. To answer your question, whether they want to help themselves is such a difficult question to answer. "Helping" for some straight spouses means doing everything possible to maintain a broken gay/straight relationship. This may even lead the couple to try a mixed-orientation-marriage which is simply more denial and prolonging the pain in my opinion. I think you're referring to getting help in a "you made your bed now sleep in it" type way. Given my own experience and what I've read here, the gay spouse goes through a prolonged period of depression following separation. Why? I think of depression in these situations as a reset during which denial melts away and the gay spouse is forced to accept reality. This leaves us with two choices: rebuild an authentic life out of the closet, which requires a lot of apologies, therapy, and introspection, or run back into our closets by starting up another fake relationship with a new "beard."      

2. Or do they enjoy the pity party they have? How about the drama they bring to the table, OMG I have never had so much drama in my life I'm over it!!!! Maybe these lost souls of sexual cause should get new hobbies or something..........I'm sorry I get so mad.........The hurting of partners and families should stop...

​Perhaps the drama serves his purpose in gay/straight relationships. As I've shared in previous posts, the gay/straight relationship often mirrors characteristics of narcissist/co-dependent relationships...mine certainly did. In the beginning, my former straight wife was attracted to my brooding, wounded nature. She felt an overwhelming need to heal and protect me, right until the very end. There is also a common phenomenon in gay/straight relationships which I've referred to as a reset, or perhaps more accurately a kind of reframing of the relationship. When the gay husband has been caught pink-handed yet again hooking up on Craigslist, sending texts to his lover, cruising gay saunas or hooking up in parks, he can't continue to deny that he's gay particularly in the face of such damning evidence. Given how much gay sex he's having, he's pretty much exhausted the "I was curious" or "it was just one time" arguments. After the umpteenth sext, hook up, or dildo delivery, the straight wife finally calls "time" and is now seriously considering divorce. His last attempt to reset the relationship is to make up some bullsh*t story about child abuse being the reason he lusts after men while hoping his long-suffering wife will fall back into "rescuer" mode. So to answer your question, I think he's throwing a man tantrum in some f*cked up attempt to win you back. Don't fall for it! He's now on his own and you should continue focusing on yourself, your children (if you have kids), and healing from a very toxic relationship. Keep him at arm's length.

​I hope that helps my friend. If you have more questions, please post again. 

Last edited by Sean (August 14, 2017 12:34 am)

 

August 14, 2017 1:16 am  #716


Re: A gay ex-husband answers your questions

From a post by Ellexoh. By way of background, her husband has just admitted to being bisexual and she's considering a mixed orientation marriage or MOM. She shared: "There is no history of cheating (I see cheating as face-to-face intimate contact) that I'm aware of....just porn, literotica, Craigslist chatting, and his internalised fantasies."

​As I've shared in previous posts, I don't believe that MOMs can work with purely gay/straight relationships. Perhaps they can work with bisexual husbands who are honestly attracted to women. But I know from experience that it's simply impossible for a gay man like me with zero attraction to women to stay with a "beard" because I was too scared to come out of the closet. I'll let bisexual men or their wives comment on whether MOMs have worked for them.

​What I wanted to comment on was this idea that Craigslist chatting is somehow harmless or "not cheating." This is just more unbelievable bullsh*t spin from gay-in-denial husbands. I too told my (then) wife that gay porn was harmless. Escorts? Harmless. Sexting? Harmless. A hook up? Just once and completely harmless. I know from experience that there is indeed a tipping point. If you are posting on this forum and your husband is chatting on CraigsList, your relationship is in serious trouble. There are countless stories from straight spouses who also heard from their "bi-curious" husbands that chatting on Craigslist with other "discreet" (read: closeted) men was harmless. One of them discovered she'd caught AIDS from her husband who was also just chatting online..."nothing more" he claimed while the bastard blithely gave his trusting wife a potentially life-threatening STD. In my opinion, CraigsList chatting and face-to-face hook ups go hand in hand. There is a even a post somewhere on this thread by a straight spouse who claimed that her husband often went to gay saunas, "but not to have sex with other men." The gay-sauna husband claimed he was roughly 20% gay in his estimation. Right then. I wrote something along the lines of, "He's not going to gay saunas for the conversation." There is definitely a bargaining stage in gay/straight relationships and it sounds something like this:

- He watches gay porn but he loves me.
- He cheated on me ONCE with a man but he loves me.
​- I found messages to his boyfriend but I still love him.
​- He wants to open up our marriage (read: openly cheat on me with men) but we still love each other.
​- He's attracted to men because he was molested as a child so clearly he needs me more than ever.  

Gay Craigslist ads, Grindr, Scruff, Hornet and the like have one purpose: men hooking up with other men. When a man posts that he's "discreet", this means one thing: I'm married and don't want my wife to find out. So let's cut the bullsh*t. When a man hasn't had sex with his wife for years, for years has masturbated to gay porn, and actively cruises on websites or applications like Craigslist, he's gay as a rainbow and ​doing a lot more than he's telling you. Having been through decades of denial myself, I too know how long and hard a process it can be to accept reality. So please don't think I'm criticizing straight spouses for having hope that their marriages will survive. If anything, I'm bashing gay-in-denial husbands who continue to lie about their true sexuality while cheating on their wives. So what's my point? If he's on Craigslist, assume he's cheating, has cheated, and will continue to do so. This puts you at risk if you're still having sex. You should therefore protect yourself by always using condoms when having sex with your gay-(or bi)-in-denial husband. Yes we always hope for the best, that's human nature. But where your health is concerned, I urge you to assume the worst to keep from being blindsided again and again by a black-belt liar and maniupulator. Ask yourself this question: did he just spontaneously tell you about his CraigsList chatting or did he reluctantly admit to it when you confronted him with overwhelming evidence?   

​I'm sorry of that stings a bit. But I do hope that helps some of you gain more clarity on this bumpy road to healing from toxic gay/straight relationships.  

Last edited by Sean (August 14, 2017 7:43 am)

 

August 14, 2017 4:31 am  #717


Re: A gay ex-husband answers your questions

Sean wrote:

.. 

 

I think my view on those things NOT signaling cheating to me....stems from our open r'ship, and the few years of  
both of us doing these things. I'm not saying it wasn't wrong, or that it didn't hurt me, or that I didn't wish he hadn't
done any of it after I told him I wasn't interested doing it anymore....just that my tolerance and experience of it made my view of it....my own, no-one elses
 


KIA KAHA                       
 

August 14, 2017 4:51 am  #718


Re: A gay ex-husband answers your questions

Thank you for responding and please accept my apologies if I hurt your feelings or offended you. I have a few questions if you don't mind:

1. If I'm reading your post correctly, did you both agree to have an open marriage?
2. Has your husband confessed to cheating with other men or does he still maintain the contact was "virtual" or via internet, chat, or text?
​3. If he hasn't yet had sex with another man, how then does he know he might be bisexual?

Thanks in advance for your answers my friend. I hope you, your husband, and family aren't suffering too much as you navigate these troubled waters. Please keep sharing as all posts/opinions help.  

Last edited by Sean (August 14, 2017 5:00 am)

 

August 14, 2017 7:30 am  #719


Re: A gay ex-husband answers your questions

Sean,
   I want to thank you for the clear distillation of the stages of the gay/straight relationship.  I find them applicable to my own situation (husband declared himself trans) as well.  No need to apologize for the reality check, both in the outline of the stages of the breaking apart of the marriage and the delusions and self-delusions.  It's useful for us straight spouses to be asked to look at the hard reality and to realize we are engaged in futile and ultimately self destructive bargaining.  

  Your post was a masterful stripping away of the wallpaper hiding the crumbling walls of the marriage that both gay and straight spouses are desperately trying to keep intact.  Both spouses are engaged in bargaining: the gay in denial spouse with himself and his own sexuality (and willing to sacrifice his wife's and his children's health and future to stay in the closet), the straight spouse with the reality that her husband can't partner with her no matter what of herself she denies or what of herself, her husband, or their marriage she rationalizes away for whatever reason she does so (he was abused...I'm not afraid to live by myself, I'm just a very caring person fighting for my marriage with a man who really does love me).  Both are doomed to failure, ultimately.  A GID spouse may stay in the closet, but that experience will keep him trapped in inauthenticity.  A straight spouse may rationalize away the lack of intimacy until the marriage is nothing but roommates with history.  Both of them will suffer the consequences in their physical and mental health.  
  

Last edited by OutofHisCloset (August 14, 2017 7:49 am)

 

August 14, 2017 8:19 am  #720


Re: A gay ex-husband answers your questions

Ellexoh,
   This might be hard for you to read and may even seem cruel or hostile, but I think your saying that because you have a history of an open relationship this means that you have a different perspective and therefore can't see what Sean details (Craiglist, etc) as signaling that your husband is gay is some world class "bargaining" you're dong with yourself.  I also think you may at some level know that you are bargaining, because after all you've chosen to come onto this forum.  I think you're stuck in a "I need to do something/I can't do something" phase. It's a phase, and I'm not condemning or criticizing you--dog knows I was a world class bargainer and denier of myself!  
    Right after my husband declared to me that he was trans, I became an active audience participant in my husband's own individual immersive sexual theatre, not just the action onstage, but helping out as a techie behind the scenes, helping with costumes, prop acquisition and management, and script.  
    So I get it: you're saying, "well, this stuff doesn't matter because our situation is different; I benefitted, too.  I can't cast stones. It means something different in my case than in most."  Sorry to say, to me it looks like maybe what you're doing is giving yourself ammunition to help yourself continue to deny and bargain. I "benefitted" too, if you count the number and quality of the orgasms I was having when accepting the invitation to play wife to trans woman. But even after a session (see, I don't even call it a lovemaking session, because it wasn't that--it was me trying to make it lovemaking to my husband, when my husband was not making love to me, but making love to himself as a woman and imagining I was making love to him as woman) I would long for my husband to want to make love to me as he used to do and be sad knowing he never would again, sad realizing that he would never again do that for me, despite what I was doing for him.  Once, after a session in which for once he didn't wear women's clothes, but still, lying on his back and raising his legs, cried out in his woman persona "I need for you to fuck me" (meaning "use the dildo on me"), he asked me "Was that hetero enough for you?"  
    Eventually, I realized that these sessions didn't signal what I thought they did and wanted them to, and I began to feel guilty for "leading him on" to believe I could accommodate myself to a sexuality that was really fundamentally at odds with and even hostile to my heterosexuality.  How could I leave him when I'd been so eager a participant?  Bargaining on my part, pure and simple; I didn't want to break the marriage, didn't want to lose the future I thought we could have, was afraid of a financially less generous retirement, thought I wasn't lovable on my own, etc. etc.
    Then I came around to thinking I did what I did then with the knowledge I had then; the more I found out about the way he thought of himself, the more I saw his behavior change outside the bedroom, the more his own idea of himself changed or solidfied, the more distorted his reality and reason became, the more I realized things were not what I thought when I'd participated in my desperate attempt to reassure myself that my husband still loved me and that I could "save" my marriage (and that I wasn't "transphobic"--I had a huge assortment of mental tools to help me construct my "house of bargaining"). 
   So my experience makes me say this: don't think that just because you had an open relationship before that it means his desire for one now, with male partners, doesn't signal either cheating or that he isn't gay (or that his claim to bisexuality isn't a cover for his being gay). I wonder: who suggested that first open relationship?  Was is it you?  If so, what were your reasons?  If it was him, what were the reasons you agreed?  What difference would it have made then and what difference does it make now that If you had known then when you first went along with it that what your husband really wanted was a way to have sexual contact with men without saying that?  Threesomes, couples, open relationships: all can be a cover, cast as benefitting you.  Someone once wrote on this forum that her husband took her to a male strip clube as a "present" to her--when he was the one who wanted the experience.  What difference does it make now that he has started it up again after you asked for it to stop (I may be confusing your story with someone else's and you didn't)?  
   So to me it's not about the fact that you had such a relationship once so you therefore can't complain about its starting up again or reinterpret the reasons for it then or now.  It's not about the fact that your having been sexually adventurous and open protects you from the reality of your husband's being gay. On this forum I have noticed that you like to refer to your husband as "my man"; as the wife of someone who declared himself transgender, this phrase struck me powerfully, as "my man" is exactly what I've lost and would like back, and I've often wondered whether this use on your part wasn't some powerful unconscious expression on your part, wishful thinking, as it were, as if calling him that would "ward off the gay."
  
   

Last edited by OutofHisCloset (August 14, 2017 8:43 am)

 

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum